When you've finished with this page, just close it. I've roamed the Net high and low trying to find out how other people pronounce ancient Greek. With very little success as far as convincing advice is concerned. So .... phth Since there are no Ancient Athenians of the Pericles era alive to show me how they pronounced: ὁ φθόγγος the sound (as in our word di-phthong = two-sounds combined) I decided to pronounce it the English way:
p-h-t-h-ongos
When learning a language we've got to avail ourselves of all the help we can get. And what is better than actually hearing the words, structures and stories, not just reading them. We learn by ear as much as (if not more than) by seeing the foreign words written, to top it all, with strange-looking letters. So, as far as I'm concerned, any pronunciation we are comfortable with, be it f or p-h is just fine. It's up to us, each of us personally, to choose and get pronouncing.
And while we are at it, what about the letter χῖ ?
chorus, chaos, chronic, chrysanthemum (from χρυσός = gold) etc.
If it weren't for the little word οὐ :οὐ changes to οὐκ in front of unaspirated vowels and is pronounced ouk. Fine. For ease of pronunciation we add a k-sound at the end of οὐ . So far, so good. But why should that simple k sound be spelt οὐχ in front of aspirated vowels but still only be pronounced ouk. It is not the k, but the following vowel that carries the h-sound, as indicated by its diacritic. There would be no need for this change from κ to χ. Again, if Dikaiopolis came back and showed me how to pronounce oukh horate (you my friends don't see), well, then I would be convinced. And would try to imitate. But he won't, so I shan't. Because, when I try to pronounce the above k-h-h in "you don't see" it sort of automatically becomes a guttural German ch sound. Furthermore, in modern Greek the letter χῖ is still pronounced like German ch. |